When my husband and I sold our respective bachelor and bachelorette pads and were house hunting together in the Denver area, our wish list included some of the usual suspects, like enough space for both of us to work from home and a backyard for our dog. But there was one harder-to-find feature we were especially hoping for: an accessory dwelling unit, or ADU.

We had a specific future use in mind. My sister-in-law has a disability, and we wanted a home where, if she ever wanted or needed to live with us, she could have independence and privacy while still being close to family.

A few months into our search, a house came on the market that checked every box, including a cottage in the backyard. At about 430 square feet, it’s completely separate from the main house and all on one level, with a walk-in shower, full kitchen, laundry area, bathroom, and a front entry as well as a back door that opens to its own outdoor space.

The cottage is actually the original 1940s home on the property. The design-build team knocked down the walls that divided it into four small rooms to create a more open layout. The original detached garage next door was transformed into a backyard bar, and a larger house was built at the front of the lot.

We knew a house with an existing ADU wouldn't sit around waiting for us to make up our minds. We were the first buyers to tour it, and our real estate agent submitted a full-price offer hours later, ahead of the planned open house. One thing in our favor is that we were buying in a high-interest-rate environment, which sidelined a lot of would-be buyers.

We bought the property largely because we knew exactly what that cottage could mean for our family someday. But what we didn't realize was just how many lives it would live before it ever served the purpose we'd originally imagined.

Our ADU Became Our Financial Safety Net

Cozy living space featuring a sofa, bed, and modern kitchen with a dining area and neutral color scheme.
Brittany Anas
Our ADU has one main living area, making it perfect for short-term guests.

I'm a freelance journalist, which means I've always had to be comfortable with some degree of career unpredictability. But as A.I. began reshaping the media industry a couple of years ago, I started thinking more seriously about backup plans. My husband and I separately built up significant equity in our starter homes, which allowed us to make a large down payment on our new place and have a comfortable mortgage. But our backyard ADU gave us even more cushion.

We live near a hospital, downtown Denver, and several concert venues and nightlife districts, so I figured we could potentially rent the cottage to a travel nurse or another short-term tenant if my freelance income ever took a hit. Fortunately, we haven't needed to do that. Instead, the ADU has delivered a different kind of return.

One of my closest friends lived in the cottage rent-free with her dogs for nine months while navigating a divorce. Giving her a place to land without adding rent to everything else she was dealing with felt far more valuable than any rental income we could have collected.

More recently, my mom stayed there while work was being done on her house. And when our first baby arrives this fall, my mother-in-law and sister-in-law will be able to stay there when they visit, close enough to help without all of us sharing the same living space during those blurry postpartum weeks. I've even started thinking of the cottage as a place where I might occasionally sneak away for a few uninterrupted hours of sleep. We’ve had a baby boom on our block, so we’ve also talked with our neighbor friends about using the space for a nanny share. It’s also been a fun spot to host everything from Galentine’s parties to out-of-town friends visiting Denver.

In other words, the ADU we bought for one hypothetical chapter of our lives keeps showing up for the chapters we didn't anticipate.

The Real Value of an ADU Is Its Flexibility

A modern kitchen featuring a stainless steel stove, microwave, and herringbone backsplash with cooking utensils and ingredients.
Brittany Anas
Modern bathroom featuring a glass shower with a gold showerhead and a white sink, complemented by neutral tile colors.
Brittany Anas
Google
Add House Beautiful as a preferred source in your Google search results.
Use your Google account to add this to your settings.

Real estate agents say that flexibility is becoming a major part of the appeal of ADUs.

“ADUs are a big selling point not only for more space, but because a separate living space can solve a lot of different problems over the years,” says Daniel Amodeo, president of Amo Realty, a brokerage with offices in 14 states. Rental income may be the most obvious benefit, he says, but “the flexibility is actually the bigger value.”

Jon Flagg, a luxury real estate agent in Newport Beach, California, has noticed the same thing. Buyers are increasingly drawn to ADUs even when they don't have an immediate plan for the space.

“Buyers realize, especially if they do plan on owning a home for years, that life changes and ADUs offer the chance to be flexible no matter what stage you are in,” Flagg says.

He's seen homeowners transform them into offices, gyms outfitted with cold plunges and saunas, guesthouses, caregiver quarters, and rentals. Some families envision them as future spaces for teenagers or aging parents.

That flexibility can also make a property attractive to a wider range of buyers when it's time to sell.

“For sellers, a properly permitted ADU can be a real value-add and can help broaden the scope of who's interested in your home in the first place,” says Tamara Mattox-Kabat, a Colorado-based senior real estate agent with Redfin. “Buyers love options.”

An ADU Can Change Along With Your Needs

Modern kitchen with stainless steel appliances, light cabinetry, and a stylish herringbone tile backsplash.
Brittany Anas

Of course, there's an important caveat for anyone buying or building an ADU with rental income in mind: Rules vary considerably by location and can change. Amodeo points out that some cities have tightened restrictions on Airbnbs and other short-term rentals, making it important to understand local zoning regulations rather than assuming an ADU can automatically become an income property.

We live in a neighborhood without a homeowners association, and we worked with a real estate agent who specializes in “house hacking,” a strategy in which homeowners offset some of their housing costs by renting out part of their property. That expertise was helpful as we considered not just how we might use the cottage ourselves, but what options it could give us financially down the road.

But I think that's also why our experience has changed the way I think about the value of our backyard cottage. We haven't made a dollar renting it out, but I’m OK with that.

It’s given a friend going through a difficult life transition a place to regroup. It’s a fantastic guest house. Soon, it will give us extra room as our family grows. And someday, it may become exactly what we originally imagined: A home where my sister-in-law can live independently while still being part of our everyday lives.

“Extra space never goes out of style,” Mattox-Kabat says.

I'd add one thing to that: Sometimes the best room in your house or space on your property is the one that can become whatever your family needs next.


Follow House Beautiful on Instagram and TikTok.