It's pumpkin season! Whether you're a fan of Halloween and its general spookiness or not, there's one thing we can all agree on, and it's that pumpkins add an undeniable pinch of fun to a time of year that's otherwise pretty grey, dreary and wet. Wondering how best to choose your pumpkin this year? Take a look at our guide...

You might assume one pumpkin is much like another, but according to the experts, there’s a knack to picking the right one.

How to harvest the right pumpkin: what to check

It’s important to make sure your pumpkin is mature before picking it, especially if you plan to use it in autumnal recipes rather than simply display it outside your home.

Here’s how to tell if it’s ripe and ready to harvest.

herefordshire, uk 29th september 2023 scenic landscape of yellow and orange pumpkins ready for harvest at a pumpkin patch in ledbury, herefordshire, england, united kingdompinterest
Chris Griffiths/Getty Images

Colour: A pumpkin’s signature bright orange colour can be a sign that it’s ready to harvest. But garden care expert and Envii CEO Olly Peabody explains that colour alone isn’t a reliable guide: 'Just because a pumpkin isn’t completely orange, it doesn’t mean it isn’t ripe. In fact, some pumpkins could be completely green and be perfectly ripe enough to eat!'

Hollow or not: Knock on the pumpkin’s exterior. If it sounds hollow, a bit like a stud wall, it’s usually ripe and ready to pick. If it doesn’t, leave it on the plant for a few more days before checking again.

Surface texture: A ripe pumpkin should feel tough rather than soft. 'To test this, gently apply pressure to the pumpkin’s skin with your fingernails. If the surface only has dents and does not puncture, then your pumpkin is ripe,' Olly says.

According to Olly, cutting the stem at the right point helps prevent damage.

'Using a sharp knife or good-quality pruning shears, simply cut the pumpkin at the stem. You should leave a minimum of three inches of the stem still attached to the pumpkin after cutting the pumpkin from the main plant stem. This will help the pumpkin to stay fresher for longer.'

fresh ripe pumpkins growing in the garden patch among green leaves.pinterest
Getty Images/Larisa Blinova

After this, give your pumpkin a wash with clean water to remove any visible dirt, mud or debris – especially if you plan to eat it, rather than carve it for decoration.

Read more: 60 creative pumpkin carving ideas to try this Halloween

For pumpkins you intend to eat, Olly explains that good storage is key. 'You’ll need to store your pumpkins in a dry ventilated area at a temperature between 10 to 15 degrees Celsius,' he says. You should also cure your pumpkin ahead of eating it, to ensure it as tasty as possible.

'To cure your pumpkin, simply place them in a warm, sunny area such as a windowsill for at least four days. The process may take a little longer, depending on how warm and sunny the area is.

'This curing process will heal any wounds or problem areas, hardening the skin and maturing any unripened fruit after harvesting.'

You can also save some of the seeds inside your pumpkin and plant them to grow your own pumpkin patch in 2027.

Follow House Beautiful on Instagram, TikTok and Pinterest