The minute Carly Parkin walked into the abandoned Sunday school, she knew where the kitchen would go. This was before she and her husband Tim knew whether they could even put in an offer, or if the 19th-century former Sunday school near Holmfirth in West Yorkshire could realistically become a home at all, as the building, along with the church next door, was listed for commercial sale.

‘We walked in and it was grim,’ Carly remembers. ‘There was mould, the ceiling was coming down and there was a stage at one end. But I looked across to where the pantry cupboards are and said, “That’s the kitchen.”’

before after sunday school renovation yorkshirepinterest
Brent Darby

Even though Tim had found the property – and suggested the viewing – he briefly wondered if Carly had taken leave of her senses. Before this moment, the couple had spent months searching for somewhere larger than the cottage they were living in, but nothing within budget met their needs: a dedicated workspace for Carly’s business SillySausageEmporium; storage space for her fabrics; and room for the couple’s furniture and three dachshunds, Ivy, Violet and Iris.

before after sunday school renovation yorkshirepinterest
carly parkin
The Sunday school before renovations began

Then, while out driving, Tim spotted the church and adjoining Sunday school up for sale. ‘We hadn’t seen them online because we were searching for residential properties,’ Carly explains. ‘The church itself came with loads of restrictions, but the Sunday school seemed more workable.’ Even though there was no chain, the sale still took seven months. ‘It was just us and the church committee,’ Carly says. ‘But there were meetings about every decision.’

When Carly and Tim finally got the keys in April 2022, the building felt as though everyone had simply walked out one evening and never come back. Tea towels still hung over radiators, crockery filled the cupboards and a calendar from 2018 remained pinned to the wall.

before after sunday school renovation yorkshirepinterest
Brent Darby
The corner lounge chair is covered in a Sanderson fabric, while the sofa, found on Ebay, is in Wakati by Warwick Fabrics. The footstool’s zebra-print fabric is from Nobilis, while the walls and pendants are in Farrow & Ball’s School House White and Stiffkey Blue
before after sunday school renovation yorkshirepinterest
Brent Darby
Dachshunds, Ivy, Violet and Iris

Four months later, and before the renovation was remotely finished, the couple moved in. There was running water, a working toilet and enough safe space for the dogs, but the rest remained a building site. ‘We were heating water in kettles and washing in buckets,’ Carly recalls. ‘We’d walk through plaster dust and piles of tools just to get to bed.’

before after sunday school renovation yorkshirepinterest
Brent Darby
Two old Parker Knoll armchairs have been reupholstered and now sit in front of the woodburner. The footstool is covered in a fabric found on Ebay

However, living on site meant work could continue every day. Apart from plastering, electrics, roofing and bespoke joinery, almost everything else was done by Tim and his brother. Every new idea Carly dreamed up came with another catch. Bargains had to be struck. ‘I wanted reclaimed tiles,’ Carly remembers, ‘so Tim said, “You’re going to have to clean the grout and dirt off every single one.”’

before after sunday school renovation yorkshirepinterest
Brent Darby
The pink cupboards are an original feature painted in Fruit Fool by Farrow & Ball, a colour repeated throughout the space.
before after sunday school renovation yorkshirepinterest
Brent Darby
The splashback is made of tiles from Otto Tiles and paired with holiday-inspired ceramics.

Because the building had started life as one large hall, they let the existing structure shape the work. ‘The windows dictated everything,’ Carly explains. ‘We didn’t want to split them with a mezzanine, so every room had to work around where the light came in.’

They decided to leave the main space open; this now houses the kitchen, living and dining area, while the other half of the home was restructured to create the bedroom, bathroom, utility room and Carly’s sewing room. Occupying the brightest side of the house, the workspace benefits from plenty of natural light, while the cooler north-facing end was turned into the bedroom, now decorated in an enveloping purple. Plumbing constraints determined the bathroom position and unexpectedly led to the freestanding bath ending up in the bedroom itself.

before after sunday school renovation yorkshirepinterest
Brent Darby
The pendants were repurposed from their original home above a pub pool table and painted in Trumpet by Little Greene. They hang over a church pew, found for £20

Salvaged materials, reclaimed furniture and old fittings made financial sense, but they also suited the building far better than anything too polished or new. Existing floorboards were repaired and reused wherever possible and the original school coat hooks were removed, repainted and rehung for dog leads and jackets. The oversized kitchen island was once a fixture in Tim’s family printing business, while the pendant lights above the dining table once hung over pool tables in a pub.

before after sunday school renovation yorkshirepinterest
Brent Darby
An enveloping deep purple – Pelt by Farrow & Ball – covers the walls, while layers of different textiles create a comfortable space

It took 18 months and a lot of hard work to complete the transformation. ‘We had a running joke,’ Carly laughs. ‘Tim would be looking for his screwdriver or his hammer, and I’d ask him what he’d lost this time and he’d always say “the will to live”.’ However, the old Sunday school now feels like home, and while the Yorkshire weather outside might be unpredictable, within, the house retains the sense of calm that first appealed to Carly. ‘The light is everything,’ she says. ‘Even on miserable days, it still feels good in here.’

before after sunday school renovation yorkshirepinterest
Brent Darby
The walls in the bathroom are painted in Pickled Okra by Johnstone’s
before after sunday school renovation yorkshirepinterest
Brent Darby
The basin was taken from an old Revolution cocktail bar

Follow House Beautiful on Instagram, TikTok and Pinterest