7 min readInterior design is personal. When it comes to your home's interior, the only opinions that really matter are those of the people who live there. But exterior design is a different story—especially if you live on a busy street or in a neighborhood with a homeowners association. The color you choose for your home's exterior is one of the first things people notice, and the wrong choice can make your house stand out for all the wrong reasons.
Unlike interior paint, exterior colors tend to be a longer-term commitment. While color trends come and go, a quality exterior paint job can last a decade or more. It’s costly to redo if you get it wrong, and some drawbacks—like fading or a color that looks harsher than expected in changing light—may not become obvious until the paint is already drying.
“Fire engine red and canary yellow are lively colors that enhance energy and emotion—they’re the party animals of the exterior paints!” interior designer Lauren Smith says. “Which may seem like a fun idea in theory, but that energy can quickly shift to anxiety-inducing. Homes that are painted these alarming colors tend to have lower long-term appeal and may be tougher to maintain visually throughout various times of year, such as Christmas, for example, when a bright red home will most certainly be mistaken for Santa’s Workshop.”
To save you from some serious painter’s remorse, we consulted designers on the worst color mistakes they’ve seen. Below, you’ll find five exterior paint colors to avoid, plus recommendations on which colors to use instead.
Canary Yellow
Yes, yellow might evoke thoughts of storybook cottages, but it might not look so dreamy on your cul-de-sac. If you don’t live on a tropical island or in a sprawling meadow, steer clear of canary yellow in particular.
“I have never seen a pretty yellow house,” interior designer Nancy Davilman says. “To me, they look tacky and out of date. Maybe if you’re in the prairie somewhere yellow can work, but I have never seen it done successfully.”
It’s more than just a tacky color choice. It can actually be a safety hazard. In Smith’s neighborhood, there’s a quiet winding street with beautiful homes that for some reason was very car-accident prone, puzzling residents. “Eventually they realized drivers were distracted by a brightly painted canary yellow home that sat on the corner like a permanent fluorescent billboard,” Smith says. “Drivers would stare in awe, unaware of the oncoming vehicle heading their way and the collision that ensued.”
This may sound dramatic, but the color of your house affects how much light is reflected onto the street, and yellow is one of the worst offenders. On bright days, canary yellow creates a glow effect that can be pretty visually startling.
Choose This Instead:
Because of canary yellow’s high-visibility and energetic nature, Smith says it’s best used as an accent color outdoors “instead of the main show.” If you want a yellowish hue for the whole house, paler approaches like Jersey Cream by Sherwin-Williams or Concord Ivory by Benjamin Moore are better options.
Black
If there was one resounding color answer among the designers we spoke to, it was black. An all-black exterior is a striking choice, and not one that bodes well in your neighborhood. You might be the best-dressed house in October, but the rest of the year it’s too intense for everyday life.
“There is a home nearby that my daughter and I drive past daily,” interior designer Diane Luna says. “We have affectionately dubbed it the ‘Bat Cave’ as the exterior is painted all-black from head to toe. It is completely out of place in a beautiful residential neighborhood!”
It’s a trend Luna has seen in many luxury mansions, but the missing piece is having the right architectural detail to support it. It’s a trend of the moment that doesn’t hold up over time, unless you have the right proportion and trim detail. It adds great contrast when used sparingly, but makes a design look heavy when it drenches the exterior.
“I understand the appeal—it photographs beautifully and feels bold and editorial,” interior designer Cathleen Gruve of Gruver Cooley says. “But in real life, it shows every pollen streak and every imperfection in the siding or trim. It also reads very different in harsh afternoon sun than it does in the moody listing photos that inspired it. It can age a home quickly because the look is so tied to a specific window in time.”
Choose This Instead:
If your heart is set on a moody exterior, Gruver says to aim for a rich, warm charcoal or coffee bean brown over a jet black. It gives you all of the drama, without the maintenance anxiety or the trend expiration date. And remember, balance is key with such an intense shade.
“Balance exterior black with a good percentage of cream-colored stucco, and warm-toned wood siding,” Luna says. “Accent with stone in lighter neutrals, and you’ll be onto something beautiful. You might even make Batman proud!”
Bold Blue or Teal
Inside the home, blue can be a source of serenity and peace. But on the exterior, a bold or primary blue is one of the worst color choices you can make. It’s a fast-track to infamy in your neighborhood, according to designer Jennifer Jones of Niche Interiors.
“It's a surefire way to get your neighbors to resent you,” Jones says. “I recently helped a neighbor with paint selection and suggested a deep navy blue, knowing that a small swatch will end up looking much more vibrant on a large exterior. They ended up ignoring my advice and going with a garish blue, and now they are officially referred to as the Smurf house.”
You don’t have to steer clear of every shade of blue. You just need to select the right one, and designers say it’s not one of the following: blueberry blue, baby’s nursery blue, IKEA blue, blue-green, teal, or turquoise. These colors don’t age gracefully, and in a few years you can find yourself regretting your choice.
“Deep, saturated blues tend to fade significantly with prolonged sun exposure, so what starts as a rich cobalt can become a washed-out version of itself within just a few years,” Nicole Forina, founder of Forina Design & Co, says. “Because fading and peeling are much more noticeable on bold colors, any imperfections in the paint job become impossible to ignore.”
Choose This Instead:
Turn down the saturation to get your blue to last you longer, like with Farrow & Ball’s Borrowed Light. Gray undertones and muted shades have a longer runway. And branch slightly outside of blue—one of interior designer Peter Spalding’s favorites is a dull forest green with soft cream trim. “You really do not want the exterior of your house to reflect tons of light,” Spalding says.
Blush Pink
Remember when the Barbie movie caused an international shortage of pink paint? Maybe that was for the best. Blush or “Barbie” pink is not a great long-term call for your home’s exterior. Jade Joyner, principal designer for Metal + Petal, says for the first 18 months, it’ll photograph beautifully, but then it’ll start to feel dated. And if you have big landscaping dreams, your shrubs and topiaries will start to look like a dollhouse in no time.
“Exterior paint should be in conversation with what surrounds it, and a hot pink home fights the landscape instead of enhancing,” Hallie Malitsky, founder of Hallie Rose Design, says. “Green lawns, boxwood, trees, none of it stands a chance. And if resale is anywhere on your mind, look at your home in the context of the street. Does it stick out like a pink thumb, or does it read as the charmer on the block? Those are two very different kinds of attention.”
Choose This Instead:
Just like with bright blues, Joyner recommends staying in the same color family, but dialing it back so it’s a softer hue. “A chalky pink instead of anything that leans blush,” Joyner says. “Those colors have been used on houses for centuries. They only look dated when they’re pushed too bright. Keep them muted, and they age well.”
Greige or Beige
Many homeowners lean toward beige as a safe, resale-friendly paint choice. But in interior designer Dani Magarity’s experience, it’s rarely executed well.
“Beige has an issue of always trying to find the balance between a shade that's neither too cold nor too warm, and then after finding the perfect shade somehow it still can fall flat,” Magarity says.
Don’t try too hard to split the difference. Gruver has seen too many homeowners choose what she calls “aggressive greige,” a muddy middle ground between gray and beige. “Homeowners often choose it hoping for something safe and neutral, but outdoors it just looks dirty,” Gruver says. “It has no warmth, no depth, and no commitment.” You’re better off committing to a color with some actual identity, like a warm taupe or soft gray.
Choose This Instead:
Choose a direction if you’re stuck in beige purgatory. If you want to go darker, aim for a taupe like Jitney by Farrow & Ball. If you want to lighten it, off-white shades like Farrow & Ball’s Au Lait provide that blank slate without it being boring. Then you can add a little more color and interest in the trim and window treatments.
