Sometimes, the best design discoveries hide in plain sight. For Caitlin Flemming, that lesson came courtesy of a dusty box tucked in the basement of a Petaluma, California, home she was renovating for the parents of a longtime family friend. Inside were original sconces from when the house was built—an unexpected find, especially since Flemming had been hunting for a few pieces of vintage lighting to give the interior a sense of history. After refurbishing the sconces and adding custom shades in Les Indiennes fabric, the pair found their way back upstairs. “It felt like we had found a little piece of the home's history that had been waiting for us,” the designer recalls.

The discovery was a fitting metaphor for the project itself. Rather than reinvent the 2,300-square-foot, three-bedroom home, Flemming set out to uncover what made it special in the first place, with the goal of creating a comfortable, character-rich retreat. There was plenty to work with, though some of it required a little digging. Every wall was coated in a heavy textured finish Flemming dubbed “elephant spackling,” while the dark wood floors and a lack of natural light made the interiors feel dated. Smoothing the walls took three attempts; refinishing the floors to their original lighter tone, meanwhile, offered a nearly instant transformation.

With the architectural foundation laid, Flemming turned her attention to the details that would make the house feel as though it had been assembled over decades. Rose Tarlow wallpapers mingle with vintage rugs, antique furnishings, and textiles from the likes of Lisa Fine and Sister Parish. Beloved pieces from the homeowners' previous residence found new purpose, while custom cabinetry by Chopwood Co. brought a welcome dose of craftsmanship to the kitchen and primary bathroom. Even the original breakfast nook table was spared, its existing base paired with a new ash tabletop crafted from wood sourced in the Marin Headlands.

They trusted us to push them a little, and in turn, they brought so much of themselves to the process.

The result is a house with an innate sense of continuity, where nothing feels precious and nearly every piece has a story. For Flemming, the process was made all the more rewarding by clients willing to experiment, particularly when it came to the spirited mix of patterns that now moves from room to room. “They trusted us to push them a little, and in turn, they brought so much of themselves to the process,” she says.

Perhaps that's why the finished home resists any obvious timestamp. “It doesn't feel like a house that was decorated,” Flemming says. “It feels like a home that was collected, layered, and lived into over time.”

FAST FACTS

Designer: Caitlin Flemming
Location: Petaluma, California
The Space: A three-bedroom, two-bathroom home across 2,300 square feet.


SUNROOM

A comfy sectional offers plenty of room to bask in the sun.

Cozy living room with a patterned sectional sofa, decorative pillows, and natural light from large windows.
Stephanie Russo
Wall paint: Swiss Coffee, Benjamin Moore. Drapery: custom, in Peter Dunham Textiles.

Located right off the dining room, the light-drenched sunroom acts as an inviting spot to soak up views of the nearby garden. A plush sectional, finished in a Penny Morrison block print, can seat a crowd for post-dinner drinks.


LIVING ROOM

A palette of neutrals reads as serene and historic.

Cozy living room featuring patterned furniture, a round coffee table, and a warm, inviting atmosphere.
Stephanie Russo
Rug: vintage, Heir Looms. Roman shades, draperies: custom, in Sister Parish fabric. Armchairs: custom, in Lisa Fine Textiles fabric. Leather chair: vintage, Elsie Green. Couch: custom, in Lisa Fine Textiles fabric.

In the living room, the original fireplace anchors the room, but it doesn’t draw too much attention, thanks to its gently curved hood and subtle texture. Instead, it sets a foundation of warmth, reinforced by a bevy of patterned furniture in various shades of brown. The vintage sconces originally found in the basement ended up residing here.


KITCHEN

A small-but-mighty space outfitted with ample storage.

Modern kitchen with marble countertop, wall-mounted cookware, and greenery in a vase.
Stephanie Russo
Wall paint: Swiss Coffee, Benjamin Moore. Backsplash tile: Zia.
Bright, modern kitchen with marble countertops, open shelves, and natural light from windows with patterned shades.
Stephanie Russo
Cabinet paint: String, Farrow & Ball. Countertop material: Calacatta Vagli Oro. Pendants, sink, fixtures, hardware: deVOL. Roman shades: custom, in Sister Parish fabric.

Because the house is very crooked (as older homes tend to be), getting all of the kitchen cabinetry and countertops to be level took patience and precision. “It was one of those projects where the final result looks effortless, but there was a lot of careful problem-solving behind the scenes,” says Flemming.

Google
Add House Beautiful as a preferred source in your Google search results.
Use your Google account to add this to your settings.

Expanding the cook space wasn’t an option, so Flemming approached space planning with a keen eye, making sure to use every inch to its full extent. “We spent a great deal of time planning the cabinetry, storage, and layout to ensure we could incorporate everything they wanted without making the kitchen feel crowded,” she adds. “It was a bit of a puzzle, but we were able to fit in all of the features on their wish list. The result feels effortless, even though a tremendous amount of thought went into making every detail work.”


BREAKFAST NOOK

A restaurant-style setup feels charming and approachable.

Cozy dining nook with a wooden table, patterned cushions, and soft natural light from nearby windows.
Stephanie Russo
Light: deVOL. Cushion: custom, in Hable fabric. Roman shade: custom, in Sister Parish fabric.

Compact and sweet, this original breakfast nook got a new layer of paint, fresh window treatments and cushions, and a new tabletop, helping it maintain its charm for decades to come.


DINING ROOM

An antique chandelier creates instant patina.

A cozy dining area featuring a wooden table, six chairs, a vase with flowers, and a chandelier overhead.
Stephanie Russo
Wallpaper: Rose Tarlow. Rug: Armadillo and Co. Chairs, table: vintage, Elsie Green. China cabinet: custom, Elsie Green.

Decidedly more moody than the rest of the home, the dining room possesses a transportive element, making every dinner party and Friday night takeout session feel special. “I especially love the patterned wallpaper, antique chandelier, and a glass-front cabinet in here, which all give the room its warm, collected character,” adds Flemming.


PRIMARY SUITE

French doors open out to a garden patio.

Cozy, elegantly decorated bedroom featuring patterned curtains, a plush bed, and a view of an outdoor patio.
Stephanie Russo
Bed: custom, in Caroline Irving Textiles fabric. Bedding: Les Indiennes, Hale Mercantile. Nightstand: Elsie Green. Sconce: Visual Comfort & Co., with a custom shade. Draperies: custom, in Lisa Fine Textiles fabric. Rug: Armadillo and Co. Chair: vintage, in Les Indiennes fabric.

“In the primary, we used layers of warm, earthy patterns to create a serene and inviting retreat,” says Flemming. A wallcovering from Rose Tarlow gives the space subtle texture and dimension, while a pair of French doors—open to the home’s garden—ensure the room is flooded with light.


PRIMARY BATH

A vintage rug adds softness underfoot.

Brightly lit bathroom featuring neutral cabinetry, a marble countertop, a large mirror, and decorative window treatments.
Stephanie Russo
Mirror: Elsie Green. Sconces: Visual Comfort & Co. Roman shade: custom, in Vanrenen Hanbury fabric.

To bring craftsmanship and storage to the primary en suite, Flemming tapped Joshua Podoll of Chopwood Co. to create a custom vanity, coated in String by Farrow & Ball and finished with marble remnant from the kitchen.


BEDROOM

Quilted bedding nods to a bygone era.

Cozy bedroom featuring patterned bedding, a bedside table with a lamp, and floral curtains against textured wallpaper.
Stephanie Russo
Bed: Shabby Chic. Sconce: Visual Comfort & Co. Chair: custom, in Lisa Fine Textiles fabric. Draperies: custom, in Carolina Irving Textiles fabric.

“We focused on adding layers of warm patterns to give the guest bedroom a cozy, collected feel, from the wallpaper and printed textiles to the vintage quilt,” says Flemming. A Rose Tarlow wallpaper acts as a subtle backdrop to it all.


About the Designer

Designer Caitlin Flemming heads a full-service interior design firm based in San Francisco, with projects from coast to coast. She believes home design should be both deeply personal and functional, and loves to combine old and new pieces together to tell a story. Flemming is also the co-author of Sense of Place and Travel Home.